Name: The Black Pearl
Brand: LEGO
SKU: 4184-1
Rating: 82 (5 reviews)

Average rating

1-4

5-8

9-12

13-16

17-20

21-24

25-28

29-32

33-36

37-40

41-44

45-48

49-52

53-56

57-60

61-64

65-68

69-72

73-76

77-80

81-84

85-88

89-92

93-96

97-100

We calculate the average rating when we've found two or more scored reviews. This set is average compared to all other sets. Read more about the ratings distribution chart here.

Recommendations

Recomended 75%

A review is considereded a recommendation when its score is above the reviewers median score or if it's explicitly said so in the review. Read more in our article about recommendations.

Price Per Part (PPP)

better

Average PPP for System in 2011 is 0.17. PPP for this set is 0.14, which is better.

All prices are in $USD, adjusted for inflation. This set is compared to other sets categorised as System. Read more about this in our article about price comparisons.

PPP is a guide, not a rule, and affected by the type of parts included. A set containing small generic parts generally have better PPP than one containing larger specialized parts.

Price Per Minifig (PPM)

worse

Average PPM for System in 2011 is 17.71. PPM for this set is 18.95, which is worse.

All prices are in $USD, adjusted for inflation. This set is compared to other sets categorised as System. Read more about this in our article about price comparisons.

PPM only takes the number of minifigs into account and discards everything else. It's a guide, not a rule.

Review breakdown

Scored reviews

Brickset Recommendation: yes 4.4 / 5 → 88 / 100

Brickpicker Recommendation: yes 8.3 / 10 → 83 / 100

Lugnet Recommendation: yes 82 / 100 → 82 / 100

amazon.com Recommendation: no 3.7 / 5 → 74 / 100

Unscored reviews

From Bricks To Bothans

Set information

Set ID: 4184-1
Name: The Black Pearl
Parts: 804
Minifigs: 6

Retail price (USD):
Original: 99.99
Inflation adjusted: 113.64

Price Per Part (USD):
Original: 0.12
Inflation adjusted: 0.14

Price Per Minifig (USD):
Original: 16.67
Inflation adjusted: 18.95

More sets:

2011 Pirates of the Caribbean Miscellaneous

Statistics:

Best Pirates of the Caribbean sets of all time Best Miscellaneous sets of all time

Other sites:

Brickset Amazon

Purchase:

Amazon

Some of these links are affiliate links. When you click through to purchase something, Brick Insights gets a couple of cents. It helps cover some of the costs of running the site. Thanks!

Brickset

Recommendation: yes 4.4 / 5 from 9 reviews

Read reviews

Brickpicker

Recommendation: yes 8.3 / 10 from 3 reviews

Read reviews

Lugnet

Recommendation: yes 82 / 100 from 4 reviews

Read reviews

amazon.com

Recommendation: no 3.7 / 5 from 131 reviews

I bought this lego set for my son's sixth birthday.He was ecstatic!This ship, when finished, is a site to behold. It's all black finish lends an air of coolness worthy of Jack Sparrow.After building the set for an hour or so my son said "I am so excited to finish this I can barely breath!"It took him all evening and later the next day after school to build it, but he has kept it intact since then.Although the ship says it is for 8-14, my six year old built this nearly by himself (he got a little frustrated with a stubborn corner piece.)I am getting him the Millennium Falcon for Christmas.Great instructions and engineering for these unique lego sets!It is also currently the only way to get Davy Jones, which also made my son very happy.

This score from amazon.com is an aggregate of 131 reviewers. The snippet above represent only one of them.

Read reviews

From Bricks To Bothans

by Tommy "roguefx" Williamson

Overall We have to say this is a good set, with some minor disappointments. While Connor is pleased with the realism I have to admit I think it could be a bit longer, and not sit quite so low in the “water". I'd like to see it with one more hull section and a slightly larger cabin in the back with a few more play features. As it stands it's a little difficult to get a figure in the cabin and really all they can do is sit in the chair at the table. It's not clear if the hinged sides are there for play access or just to keep the lines of the ship.

Read review